OUR MENU

Founded nearly a half century ago, P.Jays offers the finest handmade pizza, pasta and specialties crafted with an Old World flair—in celebration of Italian traditions, most notably quality food and family gatherings. Hand-tossed dough made fresh every morning. Signature sauce cooked slowly on the stove. The freshest ingredients used in every pizza, pasta and sandwich. It all adds up to a truly unique dining experience that only a boutique pizzeria can create.


So Live, Love, Laugh and while you're doing so treat yourself to the “Best Slice in Town.” Mangia!

APPETIZERS & SIDES

Menu

Garlic Bread
$3.99
Garlic Bread With Cheese
$4.75
Breadsticks (6 per serving)

Housemade- Served with Pizza Sauce

$5.49
Breaded Mushrooms

Crispy fried with ranch for dipping

$5.25
Mozzarella Sticks

Served with Marinara

$5.99
Pepperoni Chips

Deep fried pepperoni. Garnished with banana peppers & parmesan. Served with ranch

$4.99
Jojo Fries

w/ Flamingo City Smoke Dip

$5.99
French Fries

A large portion of our cripsy coated seasoned french fry

$4.00
Loaded Fries

Topped with Cheddar, Provolone, Bacon & Jalapeno Served with Flamingo City Smoke Dip

$5.79
2 Meatballs w/ sauce
$4.49
Sausage Link w/ sauce
$4.49

SALADS

Menu

Dressings: Golden Italian, Creamy Italian, Honey Mustard, Basalmic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Blue Cheese & Honey French. Extra Dressing 89¢ each.

House Salad

Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion

$3.79(SM) $5.49(LG)
House Salad With Cheese

Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion

$4.79(SM) $6.49(LG)
PJ's Special

Lettuce, Red Onion, Pepperoni & Pizza Cheese, 

$5.29(SM) $6.79(LG)
Deluxe Tossed

Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Pepperoni, Black Olive & Pizza Cheese

$5.49(SM) $7.99(LG)
Chicken Club

Lettuce, Cheddar & Provolone Cheese, Ham, Tomato, Bacon & Red Onion. Choice of Grilled or Crispy Chicken

$6.49(SM) $9.49(LG)
Antipasto Salad

Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olive, Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Pizza Cheese & Banana Peppers 

$6.75(SM) $9.95(LG)
* Add Crispy or Grilled Chicken to any salad
$1.99(SM) $3.99(LG)

SPECIALTY PIZZA

Menu

Barbecue Chicken Bacon

Golden BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Red Onion, Bacon, & Provolone Cheese

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB
Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo Sauce, Chicken Breast, Banana Pepper, Tomato, Cheddar & Provolone Cheese. Side of Ranch

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB
Chicken Bacon Ranch

Ranch Sauce, Chicken Breast, Bacon, Red Onion & Provolone Cheese

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB
Deluxe

Pizza Sauce, Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion & Provolone Cheese

$16 SM $19.5 LG $24.50 JMB
Dawg Pound Double Down

4 slices of your favorite 2-topping pizza and 8 cheesy bread sticks in a single pizza pie

$16.00. - LARGE ONLY
Meat Monster

Pizza Sauce, Ham, Pepperoni, Bacon, Old World Sausage, Meatballs & Provolone Cheese

$16 SM $19.5 LG $24.50 JMB
Pepperoni Power

Pizza Sauce, Double Pepperoni & Double Cheese

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB
Pineapple Express

Pizza Sauce, Ham, Pineapple, Bacon, Red Onion & Provolone Cheese

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB
Potato Pierogi

Butter Sauce, Cheddar Mashed Potato, Sauteed Onions & Cheddar Cheese. Side Sour Cream

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB
Seafood Supreme

Garlic Butter Sauce, Shrimp, Crabmeat, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$16 SM $19.5 LG $24.50 JMB
Sicilian Sausage

Pizza Sauce, Old World Sausage, Roasted Red Pepper, Banana Peppers, Parmesan & Provolone Cheese

$16 SM $19.5 LG $24.50 JMB
Steak Italiano

Garlic Butter, Steak, Roasted Red Pepper, Green Pepper, Mushroom & Sauteed Onion

$16 SM $19.5 LG $24.50 JMB
Taco

Taco Sauce, Taco Beef, Black Olives, Onion & Cheddar Cheese. Garnished with Lettuce, Tomato & Side of Sour Cream

$16 SM $19.5 LG $24.50 JMB
Veggie Supreme

Pizza Sauce, Mushrooms, Red Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$15 SM $18.50 LG $21.50 JMB

BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA

Menu

Crust: Thin, or Regular. Gluten Free Option – Available in Large Size Only | Sauce: Traditional Pizza, Garlic Butter, Alfredo, BBQ or Buffalo

Small 9” – 6 cut

$9.00
Large 12” – 8 cut
$11.50
Jumbo 16” 12 cut
$13.50
Half Sheet -15/20 square cut
$17.00
Full Sheet- 30/40 square cut
$28.00

Toppings: Pepperoni, Italian sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, White Onion, Red Onion, Black Olives, Ham, Bacon, Pineapple, Mild Banana Pepper, Anchovies, Jalapeño, Fresh Tomato, Meatballs, Salami, Taco Meat

Premium Toppings: Chicken, Steak, Peppadew Peppers, Shrimp/ Crab Mix, Extra Cheese

SUB SANDWICHES

Menu

Add Fries to any Sub for $2

Meatball Sub

Meatballs, Pizza Sauce & Provolone

$7.99
Sausage Sub

Old World Split Sausage Link, Pizza Sauce & Provolone

$7.99
Soprano Sub

Old World Italian Sausage, Sauteed peppers & onions, pizza sauce and melted cheese

$8.49
Italian Combo

Served hot or cold. Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Pizza Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion & Italian Dressing

$8.49
Steak Philly

Steak, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Provolone & Mayo

$8.49
Buffalo Chicken Sub

Crispy Chicken, Buffalo Sauce, Red Onions, Banana Peppers & Provolone. Ranch or Bleu Cheese on the side

$7.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub

Breaded Italian Chicken, Pizza Sauce, Provolone & Parmesan

$7.99
Veggie Sub

Mushroom, onion, green pepper, roasted red peppers, banana pepper, black olive & pizza cheese on a garlic buttered hoagie. Finished with lettuce, tomato & italian dressing.

$7.59

CALZONES & STROMBOLI

Menu

Additional toppings: $2.00(SM) $2.25(LG) - Premium Toppings are an Additional Charge

Classic Stromboli

Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Italian Dressing, Banana Peppers & Provolone Cheese

$11.75 SM $13.75 LG
Classic Calzone

Creamy Ricotta, Parmesan & Provolone Cheese. Served with Pizza Sauce on the Side

$9.50 SM $11.50 LG
Pepperoni Roll

Pepperoni, Provolone & a Brush of Garlic Butter. Served with Pizza Sauce

$8.50 SM $10.50 LG

DINNERS

Menu

Served with a house salad. Upgrade to a Pjays Salad for 99¢

Classic Pasta Dinners - Plain w/ Sauce

Pasta: Spaghetti or Rigatoni Choice of Sauce: Classic Spaghetti, Marinara, Alfredo 

$10.00
Classic Pasta Dinners - With 2 Meatballs

Pasta: Spaghetti or Rigatoni Choice of Sauce: Classic Spaghetti, Marinara, Alfredo 


$13.00
Classic Pasta Dinners - With Old World Sausage

Pasta: Spaghetti or Rigatoni Choice of Sauce: Classic Spaghetti, Marinara, Alfredo 

$13.00
Classic Pasta Dinners - With Meat Sauce

Pasta: Spaghetti or Rigatoni Choice of Sauce: Classic Spaghetti, Marinara, Alfredo 

$13.00
Classic Pasta Dinners - With Mushrooms

Pasta: Spaghetti or Rigatoni Choice of Sauce: Classic Spaghetti, Marinara, Alfredo 

$13.00
Classic Pasta Dinners - With Grilled or Breaded Chicken

Pasta: Spaghetti or Rigatoni Choice of Sauce: Classic Spaghetti, Marinara, Alfredo 

$13.00
Lasagna

Homemade Meat Lasagna with Marinara Sauce

$13.00
Chicken Parmesan

Italian Breaded Chicken Topped with Red Sauce & Melted Provolone on a bed of Spaghetti or Rigatoni

$14.00

WINGS & TENDERS

Menu

Wet Sauces: Mild Buffalo, Hot Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Heat, Teriyaki, Garlic, Garlic Parmesan, Hot Garlic, Hot Garlic Parmesan & Honey Mustard | Dry Rubs: Flamingo City Smoke, 6 Pepper, Cajun | Extras: Blue Cheese, Ranch, or Celery

Traditional - 6 Pieces
$7.99
Traditional - 12 Pieces
$15.99
Traditional - 18 Pieces
$23.99

*$1 for flats only, or drums only per multiple of 6

*Jumbo Bone in Wings tossed in your choice of sauce

DESSERTS

Menu

Apple Pizza

With Brown Sugar Crumble & Icing

$7.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pizza

Baked Fresh to Order

$7.50
Brownie Pizza

Baked Fresh To Order. Hot, Gooey & Delicious 

$7.50

DRINKS

Menu

2-Liters

Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, Barq's Root Beer, Fanta Orange

$3.75
20oz Bottle

Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite & Root Beer

$2.75

Food Allergy Notice

Please Note: Our pizzas, wings, salads, sandwiches, and other menu items are prepared in a shared kitchen using shared preparation areas, utensils, ovens, fryers, and other equipment. Because of this, we cannot guarantee that any menu item is completely free of allergens or cross-contact.

If you have a severe food allergy, please speak with a team member before placing your order so we can discuss whether we're able to safely prepare your meal.

Thank you for choosing P. Jays' Pizza! We are committed to providing the best possible service and accurate information to our guests.